We watched a movie when search showed it was a Christian film about the birth of Christ. It did give some details of His birth, but the inaccuracies bothered me, and the way they added violence into the beginning and end of the film was disturbing.
The film starts with baby killing, soldiers doing the bidding of King Herod. Really a mistake for a family film, where a child is traumatized right off seeing kids getting murdered. Then there is a girl whose father cannot pay the tax due, and the girl is taken forcibly into child slavery. So frightening, especially for a child to see.
There is a scene soon after where Mary is daydreaming and sees the angel Gabriel. He is dressed in white, but has no wings and is not convincing as an angel.
How they deal with Joseph’s dream: he is dreaming the crowd is going to stone Mary because she is pregnant out of wedlock. Again, a weird way to deal with this topic. Gabriel appears and tells him she carries God’s child and he should marry her. Why give the image of stoning? Terrifying and no part of the Bible story.
The three Kings from the east – strange they decide to deal with one of them as, “I have no interest, I’m not going,” then joins them. Again, not part of the Bible recounting.
The kings show up the night Christ is born. I know that is not accurate. Here is the thought on arrival:
Scholars generally believe the wise men likely arrived months to about two years after Jesus’ birth, based on the Gospel of Matthew describing Jesus as a “young child” rather than a newborn when they met him. Some also suggest they could have arrived within days of the nativity, as there is no definitive biblical evidence requiring a longer delay.
The kings in the movie do not have a visitation of the angel to turn them away from returning to King Herod.
Mary and Joseph go to Bethlehem to be registered for the census. There is no account of her on a donkey, yet in this movie she rides on the back of a donkey rather than walking, which is what she was likely doing.
There is one angel appearing to the shepherds at the time of His birth. No Heavenly chorus. No wings.
The shepherds and wise men arrive within minutes after the birth in the movie.
Then there is a scene again of ordering death to all the baby boys 2 years and younger – with images of soldiers killing toddlers and Mary and Joseph fleeing with an angelic warning.
I really want to like this movie (The Nativity), but I just cannot. There are so many missed opportunities to reveal the glory and wonder of God on earth, the heavenly chorus and the miracle of Jesus living among us. I feel it failed.
Henry came away with the idea of bad men killing babies. It did not highlight emotionally the wonder and miracle of Lord Jesus born to a human mother, living on earth and taking away our sins at the end of His life on the cross. It showed nothing of the heavenly Glory of the miracle.
We watched Polar Express as an informational movie to help Henry understand pretend – pretend Santa – pretend elves, and to talk about Lord Jesus as what Christmas is for.
The movie is engaging for a little one. A boy is picked up by a magical train in front of his house to go to the North Pole. A child watching is feeling the excitement of the dancing waiters who bring cocoa, the adventure and camaraderie with the other children of the train, and even that they are all in PJs and robes is giving the viewer a safe, cozy adventure. The final thought is the miracle of Christmas is not in the gift, but found in your heart.
Henry liked this movie. He felt safe and engaged watching it. He talked about the bell and the little boy afterward, and for a moment declared Santa is real, which was a teaching moment of Santa is a cartoon, Jesus is real, and Jesus is what Christmas is about.
We are failing to give that safety and wonder in at least films for children about the true experience of Christmas. We continued to talk about Santa as a cartoon, and that parents tell their kids he is real, but later kids realize their parents have lied to them. Henry laughed when we spoke on this topic, like he was being let in on a grown-up secret.
We saw about 10 minutes of the first Harry Potter, which Henry was very excited about. He says, “A boy just like me,” to both of these films. I found it of interest the first introduction of magic is Hagrid the Giant informing Harry he is a wizard. That is his heritage. And that actually lines up with what we know, right?
Think of it: the fallen watcher angels impregnate women, the offspring are giants. The fallen angels teach witchcraft, sorcery to the humans they interact with. We turned it off pretty fast, but Henry saw the wand that exploded things. He said, “I want that.” I said, “It’s pretend, buddy.”
I know Henry is young to start understanding any of this stuff, but he is so curious and asking lots of questions, so I am seeing how we can address in small portions what all this stuff, which took me many years to comprehend, works.

